|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
yes its the end because you still dont understand the point of my thread .
And dont write what my team want because you know nothing about it.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
Ok dude, please dont post anymore on here, im asking nicely. Make another thread and talk about me all you want, feel free.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
|
After reading whole thread i have some sugestions. And please, don't throw a meat on me, there are just my own sugestions, based on tournament rules of other games I've played before.
1. LVL 100 cap.
This rule allow almost all clans participate and give more chance to win clans with a lower lvl members. If cap is raised to - let's say - 150, clans with 5 or more 30+ lvl members will have much too big advantage on clans with single or any 30+... Its plain and simple - put on one side of battlefield a team with 5 members with sum of lvls equal to 100 and a team with a sum of 150. Now pick a winner... Now, if we have =100 lvls max cap, almost all clans have a chance to win. Just a matter of team work. Besides, 100 is good because of max lvl limit per player in gunrox. Its good but not perfect, i don't think that 5 20's could beat 2 50's anyway...
2. Picking the participants.
This is as I see big problem to solve. I see simple solution - let's say there will be a clan tourney. After announcing tournament, a week before start clan leaders post list of clan. That will be a team allowed to play on tournament. Not all at one time of course, there's still 100 lvl cap rule. No further changes possible. Its in leaders hands to keep clan together now. Teams are more flexible - some random drops, real life accidents, bans or rare UFO abductions will not ruin game plan completly. Switching members beetwen games allowed (with 100 cap of course). No more quick clan swaps - if you leave your clan and join other one, your nick is not on right list - you just cannot play. Of course a week is just an idea - maybe its too early or too late - just need to check how it will work and find best time between annoucing clan list and tourney itself. I know thats a not perfect solution but should work in my opinion. It favors the clans with loyal and devoted members, allow some nasty clan-drops before tourney (but not allow make other team stronger) but wise leaders will not annouce a random list - they should know thier own members anyway.
(I will finish my post later, real life is calling...)
to be continued...
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
Hmm if i read the thread it seems most of the posters think the same.
Just the borders makes different meanings.
I find border of 100 not really perfect because not all clans can start with a team of 4 or 5 player. All other are to strong for level 100. For example toxic too. In some weeks when all players 2-3 level stronger.
Thats why i said all clans should post the participation-list and the maximal border at announcement.
For example:
Tourney in 2 weeks.
First match 14:00 GMT saturday. 2nd match sunday 14:00 GMT. Semifinal next week saturday 14:00 GMT. Final sunday 14:00 GMT.
Paritcipationlist:
- Clan200
Player1 (30) Player2(41) Player3(38)...
Maximal Matchborder 200
- Clan100
Player1 (12) Player2(16) Player3(18)...
Maximal Matchborder 100
- Clan150
Player1 (12) Player2(16) Player3(18)...
Maximal Matchborder 150
- Clan300
Player1 (32) Player2(45) Player3(18)...
Maximal Matchborder 300
If Clan100 play against Clan150 maximal border of all players is 100
If Clan100 play against Clan200 maximal border of all players is 100
If Clan100 play against Clan300 maximal border of all players is 100
-
If Clan150 play against Clan200 maximal border of all players is 150
If Clan150 play against Clan300 maximal border of all players is 150
-
If Clan200 play against Clan300 maximal border of all players is 200
At planing of all matches you know the borders. And if clans with high level play together they can make 5 vs 5 too. Not just 3 vs 3 because some small boders. If High-Level-Clan play against a Small-Level-Clan its 5 vs 2 (like last tourney) and we all see for example toxic kick some higher player out of tourney.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
It might be really hard for some clans to fit different limits at different times.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
It might be really hard for some clans to fit different limits at different times.
Sure but maybe easier as an hard border like 100 without level 40.
I just can speak for my clan. Before start we have 2 player with level 39 and just a few exp to level. All together 3 player over level 35 so they cant play together. Other player around level 30 - 35. If our smallest player is not avaible player of Level 39 could play just with one of the other.
For example lil with 39, pimenta with 35 just fifi could fill the team because he is was smallest level with 24. If somebody of them level up they cant start.
Teams like mjx or swat cant start because they have bigger level like us inside the clan. And you said at beginning most teams couldn't start because some player wasn't online and it was not possible to create another constelation with real clanmembers.
Another side of this suggestion a smaller clan could not start because he was to low and have no real chance (for example level 8-14). With flexible borders its maybe possible this clan could wish a border just of 80. So they can play too. 5vs2 against a bigger clan or 5 vs 4 against clans like toxic. If toxic win they can start next match with one more player.
But its just a suggestion for you. You make the rules.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
Sure but maybe easier as an hard border like 100 without level 40.
it might be easier for 1 clan, but harder for 10, personally i dont like that idea. better to set hard limit for 150 thus allowing more high level players.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
|
it might be easier for 1 clan, but harder for 10, personally i dont like that idea. better to set hard limit for 150 thus allowing more high level players.
Limit set at 150 favorize big lvl clans... Clans without any 30+ members will have almost any chances to win. I don't have to say, thats there a lot more smaller lvl clans than big one...?
I really like Knut's idea with flexible limits and i think the problem Berserker mentioned that it might be really hard for some clans to fit different limits at different times its not as big as it seems to be.
I suppose Gunrox turnaments are still at testing stage, so maybe its worth to try to do next one with flexible limits?
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
Thats why i said i can only speak for my own clan. Maybe other clan-members or leaders post their meaning about this or make some diffenent suggestions too.
Its better to talk about such thing before someting is planned and then all are worried and full with critics.
An other suggestions would be just an mega-tourney of an special border. Not fixed at special clanmembers. No replacements same like single-player tourney just with teams.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
|
Right Knut, let other players write thier opinios and sugestions
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
Either way you look at it, anyway show favortizism towards a lvl group. Being 100 lvl cap, hurts higher lvls but benifiets lower lvls, being 150 cap hurts lower lvls but benifiets higher. So make in middle, 120-130 ☺, there its settled.
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
Right Knut, let other players write thier opinios and sugestions
who's holding them back? lol
if knut's gonna stop writing are they gonna appear? 😁
|
|
This post created by ignored player and thus hidden.
Double click to show.
|
![]()
|
who's holding them back? lol
if knut's gonna stop writing are they gonna appear? 😁
hihi, im stop now, my last entry for some days at this thread. But i hope for some new suggestions and meanings but i just see a few player/clans here.
I just can talk about our clan and my own impressions but i see berserker have some impressions what other feel too. But nobody know what impressions is the real feeling of the community. Lets find it out.
|
|
